Lunch on the grass
- xaviersalaart
- Nov 17
- 2 min read

Comparison between both works
1. The Representation of Women
In Manet's version, the female figure is nude, but what most disconcerted the audience of 1863 was not her nudity itself, but her confident and direct attitude, looking squarely at the viewer without shame. Her presence challenged the tradition of female nudity in academic painting, where figures were usually depicted in mythological or allegorical scenes to justify their lack of clothing.
In the contemporary interpretation, the woman is no longer the naked and vulnerable figure, but the empowered protagonist. Her clothing reinforces her dominance over the scene, marking a complete break with Manet's version. She is no longer an object of passive contemplation, but the person who occupies the space with authority, in control of herself and the context that surrounds her. In the 21st century, this reflects the change in gender roles and the recognition of female autonomy in a society that has evolved from an objectifying gaze toward equality of representation.
2. Male Nudity
While in Manet's painting the men are clothed, reflecting their dominant role in the society of the time, in Sala's work the roles are reversed: they are the ones who are naked. This reversal can be interpreted as an exploration of male vulnerability, stripping them of the symbols of power traditionally attributed to them.
The three naked men symbolize various issues: the fragility hidden behind the classical model of masculinity, the questioning of patriarchal expectations, or even the representation of a new type of relationship between genders, where authority and power no longer rest solely with men.
Conclusion: The reinterpretation modernizes the debate on gender, power, and representation. While Manet scandalized with his portrait of a confident woman surrounded by clothed men, Sala inverts these elements and raises questions about male vulnerability and female autonomy in our time. How will the modern viewer react to the work?




Comments